revisiting an old writing

We have just celebrated the 52 anniversary of our Indenpence yesterday. It was a subdued affairs, and most people I spoke to did not express any joy . Many of them were apprehensive of the direction the country is taking.

2 years age, while we were celebrating our country’s 50th Independence, I was tagged to be one of the writers on ’50 posts to independence, and my post then was the NO 17th.

I have just gone through the writings, and i think the points written are still relevant and hence I will just published it here again for the benefits of those who have not read it before.

This was what I wrote in May 2007 on our 50th Independence:

I am indeed honoured to be tagged by KTemoc as the No. 17 post in the series – 50 posts to Independence, a count down of sort to our 50th National Day on 31st August 2007. However, true to the saying that “there is no free lunch in this world”, there is a catch which is that I have to dig into my brain reserve to come out with a post on Malaysia – my perspective of how my own beloved country has done so far—  the good, the bad and the ugly.

I have always believed that Malaysia is a fortunate country. We are blessed with fertile soils producing (and top producers no less) commercial crops such as rubber and palm oils, a climate with no seasons (even though on the hot side)  so we don’t have to worry about the elements, , no natural disasters such as volcanoes and earthquakes (though we do experience some tremors when a big earthquake occurs near us, and just sometime back, we were hit by a tsunami).

Our former colonial master, the British, actually left us with a set of good roads linking all the major towns, a good rail system that links east and West coast of Peninsular Malaysia. They have also left us with a good administrative system and a English speaking civil service. They have also , by practicing racial policy of divide-and-rule, been partly responsible for some of the problems we are facing today.

Despite some misgivings about certain policies, I consider myself lucky to be a Malaysian. I was born here, bred here and most probably would die here. This is my own country and I am always proud to announce to my foreign friends that I am a Malaysian first and foremost.

In reviewing our progress as a nation, I will talk about the good , the bad and the ugly.

The Good:

Until the Asian financial crisis in 1997, Malaysia in fact has had a very good run in its economic growth. During Tunku’s and Tun Razak’s time as Prime ministers, we were the top producers of rubber and tin. With the implementation of Felda’s scheme, we became top producers of palm oils as well. 

In the eighties, Dr Mahathir has transformed our economy into a semi-industrialised nation, with the help of inflowing FDI. In the early 1990, we were NO. 4 in the ranking for FDI, which is really an achievement considering that we are a small country with relatively small population at that time.

Compared with the likes of countries like Congo, Myanmar, The Phillipines, Indonesia, Nigeria, Somalia, ivory Coasta and so on, which achieved Independence about the same time as us, we are much further ahead economically as well as in democratic practices.

We, however, should not be too complacent, because compared with the likes of South Korea, Taiwan , Hong Kong and Singapore, we did not do so well, even though countries like Taiwan and South Korea were behind us in the 1960s.

In sports, as a small nation of a few million population, we were the champions in Badminton and we have produced many world beaters in the ’50s and ’60s, when the support from the State was minimal at best. In hockey, we were once placed No. 4 in the world (in World cup1974). In soccer, we were one of the top soccering nations in Asia, and our football team did us proud by getting into the final rounds of the Olympics.

Our judiciary used to the the envy of many countries, including some developed nations, because they were fiercely independent and upright. The ordinary people and the businessmen felt secure knowing that there was always a legal avenue that they could resort to even if they were victimised somehow by govenrment machinery or policies.

Our universities, especially University of Malaya and its medical faculty, used to be one of the top in Asia. It was highly regarded, not only in academia, but also by people of other countries.

People of all races used to mix well. During my childhood, it was not uncommon to see people of all races sitting together in a Kedai Kopi and chatting.

We also have one of the best hardware for a semi developed country. We have the Twin Towers which used to be the tallest buildings in the world, we have a very good airport in KLIA, ( even though there was much controversy about whether we really need such  buildings – I will not go into this), we have a good road system like the North South Highway (controversy again about the toll agreement of course), we have also good coverage of telecommunication system, fairly good penetration of IT usage. We have a relatively good administrative system among the third world nations.

Last but not least, we have a fairly open society.

The Bad.

1. Deteriorating standard of governance. Corruption is getting more rampant. There is this perception that whenever  a project is planned and implemented , someone would gain tremendously from it. Lack of transparency and accountability are the other things that have led to a deteriorating standard of governance.

2. The NEP, which has a very good initial intention of restructuring the society to help the poor irregardless of races, have been abused and misused for personal gain, and has led to the practice of cronyism and nepotism.

 In the pretext of the NEP, abuses in interpretation and implementation of many policies occur, and the problems of racial polarisation becomes more and more acute. 

The clutches given under the NEP has also made our people much less competitive. The people becomes less productive and less diligent, with too much dependence on government assistance.

Whereas the implementation of a project should be based on the needs of and the benefits to the people, it is now often implemented based on how much certain individuals can gain from it. Hence, the NEP has made corruption worse.

3. Loss of excellence. We have lost our urge for excellence. Our universities are no more among the top in the world. Our football team was placed 149. We have not regained the Thomas cup, we have ceased to be among the top in Hockey. Our students going overseas, with some exception of course,  no longer top foreign universities regularly like before, even though we are producing  tons and tons of all A’s students in SPM exams. Even straight A’s students are not well versed with general knowledge , and could not even tell you simple historic or geographical facts.

Our police as well as the judiciary is perceived to be not like before. Civil servants especially the younger ones no longer have good command of English, and this will become a handicap in learning new ideas or exchanging views at international conferences.

The loss of excellence has everything to do with our education system which is badly in need of a total overhaul to bring back the urge for excellence in whatever endeavour we do. The NEP has also indirectly been responsible for this malaise since it has made the people less dependent on themselves and more dependent on government assistance. The “clutch” mentality has made people less competitive, and without the urge to be competitive, we will never have the urge for excellence again.

The Ugly.

Our people as a whole are getting less courteous and more rude. This was revealed by the Readers’ digest research in which it has tagged us as the third rudest country. 
Some of us don’t have the basic courtesy of standing up and giving our place to the elderly, the pregnant or the handicapped. Some of us don’t observe traffic rules anymore, except when there is a CCTV or police presence. Some of us U-turn at no U-turn place, and never observe traffic limits, some of us even never bother to stop at traffic light junction when the traffic light is red. Going against traffic in a one way street is no more rare, double and triple parking leading to blockages of traffic is common occurrence.

This is again a failure of our education system. The rudeness and the ‘Kiasu’ness have actually added stress to our daily livings, which has in turn made us more Kiasu and rude. It is a sort of a vicious cycle, and to break this cycle, we need our schools to produce caring and thinking individuals, and not selfish dudes which care only for himself.

The Future

Despite all the misgivings that I have listed above, I am full of optimism for my country. However imperfect  our system is, we are still a workable democracy. Despite some of the abuses and misconducts, we are still many steps ahead of many others. Our government, by virtue of being elected, still listens to the people. I am optimistic that the NEP would be reviewed , at least the implementation of it . The police force is showing change for the better, the judiciary, likewise, will regain its former glory.

We have among some of our younger generation of leaders, people like Raja Nasrin, which have given this nation hope . This group of fair minded people will exert their influence on the people around , doing away the ‘clutch’ mentality and regaining the excellence that I have always propounded.

In ending this post, I shall announce officially that I am tagging Lucia Lai of Mental Jog as the Tag 16.




12 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. klm
    Sep 01, 2009 @ 12:09:37

    Dr Hsu. You had some hits and some misses.My comments

    1. Malaysia rose to its peak in year 2000-2001. This was the time when Malaysia Boleh meant pride and confidence. Since then, it had been all downhill – no thanks to Badawi.

    2. Standard of governance – if anything it got worse.

    3. Loss of excellence. It is at bottom when an Indonesian university declared it will no longer accept Malaysian students because they are poor quality.

    4. You mentioned Raja Nazrin -who has since then lost his glitter.

    5. The police – it reverse direction

    6. The judiciary – the jury is till out (pun intended)

    7. MACC – %*&^#@ (unspeakable)

    8. Corruption – it had spread wider. It used to be when you only pay the bosses. Now you have to pay the office boy too.

    9. Democracy – Malaysian democracy worked when there was only BN. The ugly side of democracy reared it head when PR started to become a alternative. From police brutality, MACC selective prosecution and bull’s head (poor animal) and Indian temple.

    Personally, I think Malaysia will go through at least 10 years of turmoil before we can see any bright days ahead. That is if we do the right things.


  2. Dr Hsu
    Sep 01, 2009 @ 12:37:32

    this article was written in 2007 when some of the person mentioned were deemed to be reformers.

    How that has been changed in just 2 years.

    Te country is more divided, there are more corruptions,worsening standard of governance, and loss of excellence has become worse, as you have rightly pointed out.


  3. clearwater
    Sep 01, 2009 @ 12:44:56

    I think you should re-visit your comments regarding ‘ The Future’. It is not as rosy as you would like to believe. Two years after 2007, some important things have not improved – the government, the police, the economy, corruption, ethnic relations, religious tolerance, democracy – just to name a few. Perhaps you should talk about the recent sea change in Japanese politics and link it to the impending change in the Malaysian political landscape in the next general election. That will be more pertinent. Malaysians, too,want change.


  4. Dr Hsu
    Sep 01, 2009 @ 13:25:00

    I think you are right about the future.

    That is what revisiting is about, We revisit the things we wrote and then find out which are still relevant and which are not.

    You are also quite right in comparing the demise of LDP inJapan. No rule can pepertuate forever. Not the Roman EMpire, Not the Kuomingtan, Not the Soviet experiment, and certainly not BN.

    The signs are clear that there would be a change of government as I have mentioned recently.

    It would then signal the real beginning of a 2 party system….


  5. disgusted
    Sep 01, 2009 @ 20:07:24

    Values: I think the greed for money and material successes override social, spiritual and aesthetic values (if any, in the first place). Failure of the education system, breakdown of the role of the family institutions and the erosion of traditional values/roles.

    Governance: The ruling regime is the biggest culprit in causing social disorder, reinforcing “ethnocentricity” and power-centric. The Ministries are becoming white elephants without substantive blue-prints and visions.

    Basic Services: Food, Housing and basic utilities are deteriorating in quality and no improvement despite hailing decades after independence. Privatised or managed by monopolies, only the rich reap more benefits at the expense of the middle0incomed and poor.

    Basic Rights of Individuals: No need to comment, everybody knows the hypocrisy of the ruling regime, paying only lip service. Democratization process is stifled at best and participatory democracy controlled.

    Income gaps, quality of life, industrial development, management of resources. We are just crawling along like a tortoise.

    We lack diagnosis to this sickly and depraved political disease. This ruling government simply “owns” this country and not Malaysians.


  6. Justin Choo
    Sep 01, 2009 @ 21:04:38

    Dr Hsu,

    Pardon me for being ignorant. What is this?

    “In ending this post, I shall announce officially that I am tagging Lucia Lai of Mental Jog as the Tag 16.”


  7. Ketuanan Cina
    Sep 01, 2009 @ 22:06:37

    I’m glad I am an Australian………

    I’m glad we practise Corporate Governance……..

    I’m glad we practise Political Accountability………

    I’m glad we practise Religious Tolarance……..

    I’m glad we practise Free Speech……..

    I’m glad we practise Mateship……….

    I’m glad I am an Australian……..


  8. Nick
    Sep 01, 2009 @ 22:17:49

    I too consider myself a patriotic citizen with a love for this country that runs deeply inside my veins. Howver, I feel short-changed by our morally bankrupt politician/leaders. Najib has lost his moral standing for not being able to clear his involvement in Aminah’s case. I don’t think the average Joe will ever forgive him for that. UMNO and BN will pay the ultimate price in the next GE. Privately, I regard Najib as a capable technocrat but he has no moral bearings. His other involvement is in the Perak fiasco. The so-called “independent MACC” has now been exposed as a political hound-dog for UMNO. They too have to account for TBH’s murder. I am sad for my beloved country.


  9. klm
    Sep 02, 2009 @ 12:09:30

    Hey Australian. Don’t rub it in. Keep your happiness to your self. 😦


  10. Meng
    Sep 02, 2009 @ 13:42:03

    Hope this ugly trend continues
    ….becomes a stepping stone for a change in govt. Thats what we want..don’t we … for a better future.


  11. CYC
    Sep 02, 2009 @ 14:28:18

    Malaysia is not of the radar for ASEAN watchers. Interestingly, the focus is none other than our biggest immigrants supplier- Indonesia. What a joke. all the while we look down on them as second grade and now they are regarded as the rising star of ASEAN or even ASIA. There is only one answer: There dare to look at themselves in the mirror and reinvent themselves. Whereas in Malaysia we prefer to use a Magic mirror to portray ourselves as the ever lasting beauty and dream on.

    But its not end of the world as i still see light at the end of the tunnel. GE12 has shaken up a lot of people from their dream and start to think critically about the future of our country. This applies to Malay as well.

    I don’t think Najib can be regarded as a capable technocrat. He has no visible achievement to show. Remember how he as the edu. minister screwed up the engineering faculty of some local universities by reducing a year of the full course and thereby accelerated the down fall of its quality. Of course he revert to its original course duration after discovered his mistake. May be he can be a good schemer with ill intention, on condition to be backed up by masked enforcers.


  12. Dr Hsu
    Sep 02, 2009 @ 15:26:59

    YA, Keturunan cina,
    It is like attending a funeral with joy and while everyone else is in a sad mood , you sing with joy and happiness….

    Even if what you said is true, keep it to yourself lah, because you are making all of us even sadder….

    🙂 😦


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: